Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Response to Mr. Frank J. Gaffney's article on The Washington Times

Mr. Gaffney’s article can be best described as unsubstantiated propaganda and blatant fabrication. It is neither journalist nor scholarly and the editors at The Washington Times have chosen to diminish their paper’s reputation by publishing it. Nothing in the article is explained or backed up and one can only assume a prejudicial attitude against Muslims caused him to write it.

What is the point of attacking a group of people trying to open a new charter school? Is Mr. Gaffney unaware that charter schools present a much needed educational alternative for students in this country and overall are seen as a very positive development? Is he unaware that high performing charter schools are often duplicated in various locations and that some of the same educational models they use are employed in regular public school districts? If Mr. Gaffney is concerned about the state of education in America why not look at the real problems like the ever present problem of unequal tax basis’ in the city versus the county leading to resource poor schools versus resource rich; or the skewed emphasis on student testing as the “be all and end all” of school performance.

The article is propaganda because he claims that Chesapeake Science Point had “little or inconsistent improvement”. All one needs to do is look up Maryland Department of Education’s “Charter Schools Annual Report 2011”1 to see Chesapeake Science Point achieved >95% proficiency in Reading/English for 2011 and 93% proficiency in Math/Algebra for 2011; very high numbers. Is it significant that in 2009 the numbers were 97% for Reading/English and 98% for Math/Algebra? Absolutely not. The facts are distorted for the author’s purpose.

The article is slander and fabrication when referring to the Islamic spiritual leader Fethullah Gulen as “supremacist” and “autocratic”. This is a man who Muslims look up to as a beacon of spiritual guidance through his prolific writings urging love and tolerance. Any objective person who looks at the life and books of Mr. Gulen will conclude he is an inspired moderate Islamic scholar. Mr. Gaffney must be more interested in war than love of his fellow man.

Mr. Gaffney clearly knows nothing about Turkey and seeks to spread lies by claiming it is an “Islamist state”. Does an Islamist state forbid women with hijab to work in the government? Truth is that Muslims in a majority Muslim nation have not been able to practice their religion freely for decades and the current government is simply moving in that direction.

The local parents and officials plus education experts are the persons qualified to decide about charter school proposals; not a biased “journalist” with an agenda.

By Charter Advocate

Source: http://www.charteradvocate.org/op-ed/153-response-to-mr-frank-j-gaffneys-article-on-the-washington-times

More Articles:

Charter schools making headway in communities

Charter schools making headway in communities
It was 20 years ago that Gov. Pete Wilson signed the California Charter Schools Act into law, and California became the second state, after Minnesota, to approve charter schools. With the governor’s signature, the door in the Golden State was opened, creating an innovative educational laboratory. New theories, practices and academic programming could be introduced with the sole purpose of positively impacting students with a specific five-year timeline in place.

The traditional school districts have watched closely as these schools have successfully taken on some of the most resistant students, in some of the toughest neighborhoods. The myth perpetuated by some naysayers would have you believe that charter schools only take the “good kids,” the “successful students,” etc. This is simply not true.

Over the last two decades, numerous charter schools have closed due to financial insolvency or a failed academic reputation. Taxpayers scratch their heads wondering why you can close a failing public charter school, but when traditional programs nationwide have the same issues, these schools are not closed. Communities and their children struggle and suffer as a result of this double standard. We are fortunate in our local community to have some great traditional school models that consistently make academic gains. Families are enjoying the high-quality options available in traditional and charter schools that were not available even a decade ago.

Charter schools have made headway in communities across America over the past 20 years and are now serving 5 percent of public school students. Although the reputation of charter schools is strengthening, there is still a sector of the public that is unaware that charter schools are indeed publicly funded. Over the last two decades, charter schools have gotten a bad rap by having some claim that these schools are the panacea for the public school system. Charter schools are merely educational models established to add to the academic options available in a community to help meet the needs of all students. What is best is when the local school district views the successes at charter schools, understands that these schools are bettering the educational landscape in their communities, and as such, implements innovation and change that benefit students in the traditional public school.

Although they serve public school students, charter schools from their very inception in 1992 have not received per-student funding at the same level as traditional schools. It is true that charter schools are expected to accomplish more with less. The funding gap created 20 years ago continues, and the inequity creates a greater burden on charter schools to produce sustainable positive outcomes with students over the long haul. Charter schools have less in state funds to budget with, and in most cases are required to provide for their own school facilities. Traditional public schools have the benefit of full funding per student and a facility provided for them by the state.

Charter schools have the freedom to operate outside much of the established education code. However, these schools are held to a higher standard when it comes to their academic outcomes and financial management as established in the charter school legislation. For instance, the promise was made that when these schools fail, they will be closed. Charter schools are also held to a higher standard when it comes to public critique. Numerous articles and publications have taken potshots at charter schools at the expense of shifting the focus off the challenges traditional schools face in dealing with 95 percent of public school students.

As the celebration of the 20th anniversary of charter schools culminates in San Diego in March 2013 with the California Charter Schools Association statewide conference, I take great pride as a charter school developer and operator. For almost 13 years, The Classical Academies has partnered with our parents and our students to achieve academic and social success. This experience reminded me of the value our state’s charter schools bring to the community of public education. The students’ successes far exceed the simple test scores we produce or the accolades and awards that have come as a result. Our state’s charter schools immensely benefit those whom we serve and help to improve the educational landscape that is part of the economic development efforts needed to improve our individual communities, and our state as a whole.


Published on North Country Times, by Cameron Curry

Monday, November 5, 2012

Charter schools growing in Sonoma County


Laura Comyns leads sixth grade band practice at Sonoma Mountain Charter School
in Petaluma, Thursday, Nov. 1, 2012.
(Crista Jeremiason / The Press Democrat)

Sonoma County is at the forefront of the charter school movement in California with 11 new schools opening this year, second only to massive Los Angeles County Unified with its nearly 660,000 students.

Nearly a quarter -- 23 percent -- of Sonoma County's 70,700 kindergarten-through-12th graders are enrolled in charter schools. Just two years ago, 13 percent of Sonoma County students were in charter schools.

Today, there are 56 campuses working under 51 state-issued charters. Fifteen years ago, there were two charter schools in the county.

The trend reflects districts' efforts to attract students in an increasingly competitive environment and a calculated assessment of how to maximize dwindling state funding for public schools.

In many cases, charter schools can pull in more state funds and with fewer restrictions while also being free of interdistrict transfer rules. Students do not need permission from their home district if they want to attend a charter school -- a key factor as Sonoma County's 40 districts compete for students and the key portion of state funding that is based on enrollment.

"They are trying to use the system to their advantage," said Steve Herrington, superintendent of the Sonoma County Office of Education. "I think people are starting to figure out, 'If I can increase my revenue, I'll do it.' I think you'll see more of that as word of mouth of that spreads."

"I don't begrudge them any of it," he said.

The trend is not isolated to Sonoma County. In California, 1,065 charter schools serve 484,000 students -- a 17 percent increase over last year. This fall, 109 charter schools opened to students. Read more...


Published on www.pressdemocrat.com, November 4, 2012, Sunday

Staff Writer Kerry Benefield writes an education blog at extra credit.blogs.pressdemocrat.com She can be reached at 526-8671, kerry.benefield@pressdemocrat.com or on Twitter @benefield

Monday, October 15, 2012

Book on Fethullah Gulen's teachings to be taught at Belarus universities

A group of academics from Belarus were in İstanbul on Tuesday for the presentation of the book “Social and Philosophical Aspects of the Teaching of Fethullah Gulen: The Look of Belarusian Intellectuals,” which will be used in the county's universities as a course book.
The academics, who are experts in the fields of philosophy, sociology, political science and philology, compiled the book, which is dedicated to the ideas and published works of respected Islamic scholar and intellectual Fethullah Gulen.

Anatoliy Rubanov, the dean of Belarusian State University's faculty of philosophy and social sciences, noted that the country has started to learn about Turkey in the last 20 years. Rubanov stated that Muslims and Christians live peacefully in Belarus, saying: “Muslims are always very tolerant and gentle. If somebody in Belarus says that Muslims are violent and aggressive, nobody believes him. Fethullah Gulen shows us the value of tolerance.”

Professor Svetlana Vinokurova, vice rector of the Belarusian State Academy of Arts, said that the name of the book has a special meaning for the academicians. “I do not know what “to look” means in Turkish, but, in the language of Belarus it means love and liking at first sight. When Belarus intellectuals looked at Fethullah Gulen, they liked his teachings. It is not possible to appreciate the teachings of Gulen immediately as he is a deep intellectual, philosopher and wise person,” added the vice rector. Vinokurova also noted that Gulen has established indestructible bridges between Turkey and Belarus, and she gives high praise to Fethullah Gulen for his contributions to world peace.

“When I first learned about the teachings of Gulen, I saw that the ideas of Gulen are notions that might draw the attention of every person. It was impossible for us to ignore his teachings. The most significant reason for compiling such a book was to acquaint others with the valuable ideas of Gulen and help people in our country learn about his teachings,” continued Vinokurova.

According to Professor Marina Tenyanko, the book is not compiled through the eyes of a journalist or some citizen, it is a synthesis of results obtained from scientific research. Saying that Gulen has demonstrated what can be achieved though tolerance, mutual respect and love, Tenyanko added: “Gulen's thoughts make mutual interactions [between people] inevitable. Interactions can result in peace or war. Thus, people should understand each other to maintain good interactions.”


Published on Today's Zaman, 10 October 2012, Wednesday

Tuesday, October 9, 2012

An untold African story: Gulen Movement activities

 
I had the privilege of traveling to Africa recently. It was somewhat a whirlwind tour of 4 countries - South Africa, Tanzania (including Zanzibar), Kenya and Ethiopia. It was full of many surprises. I hope to share some of my thoughts and feelings over the course some words in this article.
The purpose of this journey was to discover and note the Hizmet activities (commonly referred to as the Gulen Movement in academic circles). For the uninitiated, Hizmet is a loosely connected group of individuals and NGOs inspired by the ideas and ideals of Fethullah Gulen - a Turkish Muslim scholar and thinker. The movement's activities span some 140 or so countries occupying an important place in the field of education, intercultural dialogue, health and relief activities. The main emphasis is a selfless approach to serving all others while personally gaining God's pleasure.

During my visit to Horizon International School in Johannesburg , which is privately funded, I met one of the teachers. He was a local young man who happened to also be a graduate of the same school to which he was now a teacher. His warm smile gleamed over his humble demeanor. He took me on a tour of the school. Many doors and windows were reinforced - unfortunately robbery was one of the common crimes in the area. Only the week before some new televisions were stolen. Like his peers this teacher was dedicated to his teaching, being a role model for each of his students - as were his teachers who only were teaching him a few years previously - now those same teachers were his colleagues. He had a great deal of respect for this school. It had taken him out of the slums of Soweto. Even more miraculous was his own personal family story.

He was kind enough to invite us to his home - now out of the slums. His mother was a pastor of a local 500 member Protestant church. What stood out in this household was the story of his missing siblings. He had fours brother. The two older were now in prison for murders, having received 40 year prison sentences . The two younger, (a sad irony) had been killed in gang fighting. He was the success story in the family. His mother, protective of her son, was the proudest mother in the neighborhood. And pleased to have her son associated with and teaching at this Hizmet school.

The essence of these schools is typified in the above story. Taking individuals and their associated families and being a catalyst for them to shine - to remove the despair of the communities they belong to and the gruesome social conditions they may find themselves in. The school communities that are formed do not only play a positive role in the lives of its students, but as part of the wider school family touch the lives of students’ families, their relatives and friends and the neighborhoods from which they come. Such Hizmet schools - and it’s becomes quite fitting and appropriate that the movement calls itself hizmet meaning ‘service’ - become beacons of hope as graduates play a role in giving something back through service. This can come in the form of volunteering time, financial support - or those that are so moved by the teaching vocation, come back to teach at the school.

The ripple effect these schools have is tremendous. They provide a safe haven, a kind of ‘peace island’ - a term coined by Gulen - for all those associated with the school. Those not directly associated with the school take comfort in knowing the school is a role model for other educational institutions. And just as important they show-case that no matter how adverse the conditions are that stories like the one above are possible and with time probable and expected. Given the conditions, the teachers of these hizmet schools have outdone themselves,. They should be proud of their achievements but yet resilient to the excesses of immodesty. Such success breeds success and in an area that can be barrain of ‘good news’ this school stands out and needs to be applauded.

And the moral to the story ? These schools are doing fantastics things in many remote places under very difficult circumstances servicing students and families that are also in great need. And this and other stories need to be both understood and told.

Kudos to them !
by Emre Celik
President of the Rumi Forum

Published on www.fethullahgulen.org, 05 October 2012, Friday

Friday, October 5, 2012

The Gulen Movement-Inspired Schools Effect: Muslims and Christians connect for peace

Fountain Magazine held a conference recently, titled "Peacebuilding Through Education", in New York in cooperation with the Peace Islands Institute. Some institutions were honored with the best practice award, as they have served the peacebuilding under difficult conditions. Among the honorees was The Filipino–Turkish Tolerance School (FTTS), Zamboanga, The Philippines. Below is an article about this school serve peacebuilding. The article also includes a story about some Kurdish youth in South Eastern Turkey.
Filipino-Turkish Tolerance School
By Suat Erguvan for Silent Heroes, Invisible Bridge

Most children of the picturesque city of Zamboanga in the Philippines' troubled south are groomed to be cautious in making friends believing in a different religion.

Zamboanga Peninsula, the sixth most populous region and the third geographically largest in the Philippines, is home to 70 percent Christians and 30 percent Buddhist and Muslim people.

The peninsula has been in the headlines for Moro Islamic Liberation Front's militancy against security agencies. The Muslim outfit brands its actions as 'freedom struggle' which has taken heavy toll on civilian lives over the past two decades.

The Christian and Muslim communities have adapted to live in a tense equilibrium, with fire fights and bomb blasts claiming precious lives on one hand, and soaring number of unconstitutional disappearances on the other.

Wherever the two enraged communities live side by side, traffic on the roads dividing them becomes litmus test for peace or unrest in the vicinity.

While compatriot tourists visit the country's southern peninsula exercising caution, some foreigners are seen calmly working in a Zamboanga school.

Since 1997, Turk educationists are sowing the seeds of tolerance and co-existence through the Filipino-Turkish Tolerance High School located in the heart strife-torn region.

With humble beginning of 89 students, the institution today has boarding and teaching facilities for over 1,000 students. The school gets equal attention of Christian and Muslims parents and their offsprings.

"It also has one of the best dormitories not only in Zamboanga, but in Mindanao. The Filipino-Turkish Tolerance School, considered one of the best in the region, has produced a number of students that topped in many international competitions and were even cited for their excellent educational skills," noted The Mindanao Examiner newspaper in one of its story in 2007.

Encouraged by the vision of a Turkish Muslim scholar, M. Fethullah Gülen, over 1,500 non-governmental Turkish educational institutions have spread to almost 115 countries worldwide.

The schools, also working in collaboration with local businessmen, strive to provide students with a learning environment to "make them acquire solid competencies in critical thinking, creative problem solving, consensus building, informed decision making and technical literacy."

Fr. Thomas Michel, Ph.D, Secretary General of Interfaith Dialogue Council in Rome, Italy, visited the Turkish tolerance schools in 1995, in Zamboanga.

"The Turkish and Filipino staff's proud claim was a stunning reality for me as Muslims and Christian students were getting education with true spirit of a culture of dialogue and tolerance," Fr. Michel shared these remarks with gatherings around the world.

He noted that children befriended their class fellows regardless of religious divides, thus their parents not only started communicating with each other but also eventually cooperate for children and community's future both.


During a visit to Turkey in September 2009, Philippine President Gloria Macapagal-Arroy expressed need for increase in the number of Turkish schools to help "strengthen mutual relations". She vowed to learn from Turkey's experience "in helping the people of different faiths in our nation to accept one another."

Last October, Philippines' Ambassador to Turkey Pedro Chan said his country wanted to open honorary consulates in Turkey's northern province of Samsun and northwestern province of Bursa.

The Philippines is not an exception in strengthening bilateral relations with Turkey after fruitful contribution of schools. Many African nations saw following the Turkish embassy years after the voluntary Turkish schools made their mark.

Recollecting his experiences in the Philippines, Ahmet Yamakoglu, former Principal of the Phillipines-Turkish Tolerance School, recalls a meeting of Kayseri philanthropist businessmen with Governor of Zamboanga Mrs Maria Clara Lobregat.

Ahmet quotes the governor as saying, "You have changed the misconceptions formed in our minds owing to the unfortunate clashes between the Muslims and Christians, and you made us love Muslims and Islam."

On occasion of the Philippines National Day, Ahmet recollects, "When our students were parading before her, she stood up and announced to the public: And now my new children are passing out before us!"

This success did not come in platter for the Turkish educationists. Long after submitting papers for opening schools in Manila, the Turks received no results owing to the deep-seated suspicions of the central government about Muslims.

Only in 2001, the final decision for opening the school was passed; however then slow-moving bureaucracy still had question marks about presence of Muslims educationists in the conflict zone. Until Mrs Maria assigned her parliamentarian son Celso Lobregat to facilitate her Turkish friends with the processes, hopes were dim.

Celso Lobregat told his politician colleagues, "We fought with Muslims for many years in the Mindanao region. There might have been no bloodshed in the south if we had them many years ago."

Thus, the Turkish NGO got permission in style to open more branches back then.

Before dying Mrs Maria bequeathed her wish to Celso Lobregat to be the beneficiary of the Turkish schools in the Philippines. Lobregat became the Governor of Zamboanga and Turkish school quietly spread their message of co-existence and tolerance.

Such experiences have borne fruit in Turkey as well where Kurdish militants are attacking civilian and security personnel indiscriminately, alleged at the behest of external factors.

Abdullah Aymaz, a Turkish educationist, recalls a touching incident involving two Kurdish-speaking students who went on rampage in school 15 days after enrolling and lodging in the school.

Realising sensitive nature of the region, the principal treated the students with affection.

One of the students, whose name has been kept anonymous, is quoted as saying: "We were told so many negative things about you that we hated you and we came to burn the school, but we couldn't."

In another incident, a student from Cizre - a Turkish town near the Syrian border - wrote to the principal, "Until recently, I used to see Turks as our sworn enemies but now I loved you all. If you had come here earlier, terrorism might not have been here." The youngster regretted about his uncle who has adopted Kurdish guerilla lifestyle in the mountains.

The bar of expectations from the Turkish schools' peacebuilding role is rising world over as many Muslim and non-Muslim geographies, too, long for tranquility and peaceful coexistence.


Published on Silent Heroes, 04 October 2012, Thursday

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Charter school opens with exorbitant waiting list


Six hundred children are on waiting list for Thomas Edison EnergySmart Charter School


After three years of planning and paperwork, the Thomas Edison EnergySmart Charter School (TEECS) opened its doors in September for children in kindergarten through fourth grade.

The school, located in Franklin but serving children from North and South Brunswick as well, focuses on technology and energy resources in addition to the New Jersey core curriculum.

“We want the children to understand nature and the resources available to us,” Raja Govindaraju, curriculum supervisor and special education supervisor, told the Sentinel. “We are taking our children back to nature and to understand the implications if we don’t take care of Mother Earth.”

“We want to focus on solar cell energy, hydropower, and those sort of energies that we are using through everyday life,” said Head Person Yildiz Oguz.

For September and October, the curriculum will focus on recycling, incorporating it into lessons across the disciplines.

“The children will talk about how trees are important to us, why it’s important to recycle, and how we protect the environment and make the earth a better place to live in,” Govindaraju said. “There is non-fiction text and articles about recycling. We also integrate [the other subjects] with recycling, and we will take field trips to recycling centers in the community.”

Charter schools are primary or secondary schools that are part of the public school system and receive public funds, but frequently put a strong focus on a particular field in addition to the state’s core curriculum. They are often toted as an alternative to public schools and are attended by choice.

TEECS filed its application to start a charter school in 2009 and their charter was granted in 2010. After its awarding, charter schools need to re-file for permission each year until the school starts, unless the application is denied or not renewed. Typically, finding a space zoned for a school is the most difficult step, and is one that often ends the charter process for many would-be institutions.

TEECS found space in the same building as Central Jersey College Prep, an unaffiliated charter school, Oguz said. He explained that TEECS received $500,000 of federal funding over three years, money used to purchase basic necessities to start the school.

“We were granted a federal starter budget, and over the summer we started using the first budgeted payment,” Oguz, said. “We’re only allowed to use it for starting the school, such as for furniture, books, and computers.”

Charter schools receive money from the state in accordance with the amount of children enrolled. Public education is calculated by a certain cost per child, and that amount of paid to TEECS for operational costs.

Enrollment for the 2012-13 school is at its maximum capacity of 210 children, with a waiting list of an additional 669 seeking a spot for the current school year.

Without advertising, Oguz said, the school received over 100 applications just for kindergarten.

TEECS relies heavily on the use of technology, both in the classroom and out. Teachers have access to iPads to give interactive lessons using “smart” classroom boards, and an iPad cart is stocked with enough devices so that each student in a class averaging from 18 to 24 students can use an iPad for an interactive lesson. A smartphone application for Android and iPhone gives children and parents a new way to keep track of homework, assignments, grades, and behavior marks, as well of use of the Dropbox program to submit assignments. Miniature robotics called Little Bits will be incorporated into technology classes, and additional technologies, such as robotics, are in the works for later in the school year. Lunches are swiped for with student IDs with the parents paying the bill online.

Even with the strong focus on technology, education consultant Lynette Tannis explained that the emphasis on language arts, handwriting, and other “non-technical” subjects is strong.

“Implementing a balanced literacy bloc within the school allows for creativity,” Tannis said. “Even when there’s a mini-lesson when students are in smaller groups and working together, there’s still a focus on the core literacy instruction.”

Students are divided into two classes, “gifted” and “talented.” The “gifted” class has 22 to 24 children, and moves at a faster pace to challenge the students. The “talented” class has 18 students for individualized attention and moves at a slower pace. The purpose, Oguz said, is to level out the playing field in each classroom, both for the teacher and the students.

Parents are also highly involved with their children’s education. Instead of parentteacher conferences being held at school, teachers make visits to the home, which Govindaraju said is key in order to understand the child better.

“I believe that a home and school connection is extremely important because there are the two major groups where the child spends most of her life,” Govindaraju said. “In order to make a connection to the child, you need to know where he or she is coming from and talk to the parents to understand their philosophy and values.”

“Without this connection, a student may come home and say one thing to mom and may go back and say another thing to the teacher,” Tannis said. “This allows the students to see that mom and teacher are on the same team and will help contribute to the child’s success as a student.”

Govindaraju said that parents and children alike have been receptive to home visits.

“Most parents are thrilled, and even the child is surprised to see the teacher really care for her,” Govindaraju said.

However, with each charter school that opens its doors in September, there are several who are not able to take the final decisive steps to becoming a school. The Princeton International Academy Charter School (PIACS), which intended to serve South Brunswick children, went through the same process as TEECS, but was unable to acquire a building and its charter renewal was rejected for the 2012-13 school year.

“This charter is, for lack of a better word, dead,” said Kristin Epstein, vice chair of the school’s board. “The board is in the middle of dissolving.”

PIACS’s theme would have been a Mandarin Chinese language immersion program, led by Dr. Bonnie Liao, who started language programs and private schools in Bergen County and Princeton.

“She heard from some parents who had one child in the private school, and by the time their second child came around, they didn’t think they could afford to send them there,” Epstein explained. “She noticed that people were doing excessive things to teach their children Chinese, like sending their kids to camp in Beijing, and she noticed a need for a charter school in the area.”

PIACS applied in 2009 but delayed the start date for three years in an ultimately failed attempt to find a building. PIACS faced intense opposition from the public schools, which Epstein believed eventually led to its rejection. There are no intentions to re-apply for PIACS.

“As a charter school, we can adapt faster and try more pilot programs,” Epstein said. “We need to have the right to be able to fail — if one program didn’t work out, we will learn from the next one.”

That spirit of open communication and flexibility is something that TEECS is carrying on in its curriculum.

“Education has long been criticized as being a mile long and only an inch deep, so we want children to find ways to really delve into a subject,” Govindaraju said. “We want to get input, see how teachers are responding and building into every aspect, and then we will change it.”


BY STELLA MORRISON
Staff Writer


Contact Stella Morrison at smorrison@gmnews.com.

Source: http://ns.gmnews.com/news/2012-09-27/Schools/Charter_school_opens_with_exorbitant_waiting_list.html

Saturday, August 18, 2012

Turkish school opens in Kigali

The premises of Hope Kids Academy, which opens on October 8. The New Times / Timothy Kisambira.

Hope Kids Academy, an international Turkish school, has opened its branch in the country under a Rwandan-Turkish framework.

The school is located in Nyarutarama, Gasabo District.

Speaking with The New Times yesterday, Isa Gokturk Yilmaz, the Headmaster of the school, said studies will commence on October 8, adding that from Nursery one to two, each kid will be paying a registration fee of Rwf125, 000, and tuition of Rwf1.3 million per term.

Foreign students will pay a tuition fee of Rwf1.136, 000, he added.

He added that Rwandan pupils, from Primary one to three, will be paying Rwf1.4 million per term in tuition, while foreign pupils will pay Rwf1, 460,000.

“The idea is to give Rwandan children an international exposure, but ensure they retain their culture,” Yilmaz said.

He said the school will be offering Cambridge primary International programme with a strong emphasis on science, Mathematics, ICT teaching with smart boards.

The school, which will use English as a medium of instruction, has already recruited 11 teachers, will also teach several languages including French and Turkish.

According to the schools administration, each nursery and primary class will have between eight and 12 pupils.

Yilmaz the decision to open the school came after a visit to Turkey by President Paul Kagame earlier this year. “The two countries enjoy a brotherly relation”.

Rwanda and Turkey last month signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) that provides for a cooperation framework between the two countries.

The MOU was signed by the Minister of Foreign Affairs and Cooperation,

Louise Mushikiwabo and the Deputy Prime Minister of Turkey, Besir

Atalay, during the latter’s visit to Rwanda.

Although its tuition means the school will be out of reach for the overwhelming majority of Rwandans, ordinary people have welcomed the development.

Albert Ndemezo, a resident of Kacyiru in Kigali, said the new school will contribute to the development of the country’s education sector.

He said more international businesses should invest in the country.

Source: The New Times

More news: http://www.charteradvocate.org

Thursday, August 16, 2012

President of Republic of Benin praises Gulen-inspired schools.


President of Republic of Benin Dr. Thomas Yayi Boniexpressed his appreciation for the work of Gulen-inspired schools that opened in his country. He said, “It is impossible to neglect such issues as healthcare and education. These schools are strengthening our historic and cultural ties. We look forward to making strategic cooperation with them”. Dr. Boni visited Turkey as part of his work trip organized by TUSKON (the Turkish Confederation of Businessmen and Industrialists) during which he discussed political, economic and business ties between Turkey and the Republic of Benin.


English translation retrieved from fethullah-gulen.net, 11 August 2012, Saturday
Original article [in Turkish] published on Zaman, 10 July 2012, Monday

Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Universal Schooling and Gulen-Insipred Schools

Although universal schooling has been adopted as a goal by international organizations, bilateral aid agencies, national governments, and non-profit organizations, little sustained international attention has been devoted to the purposes or goals of universal education. What is universal primary and secondary education intended to accomplish?

The project on Universal Basic and Secondary Education (UBASE), based at the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, recognized a lack of consensus within and among countries and a lack of focused international discussion on the desired content and aims of basic and secondary education.

This book offers views from Asia, Africa, Europe, North America and South America on the purposes of universal education while considering diverse cultures, religions, and professions. It is the first book in which renowned authors from around the world have proposed, considered, and debated goals of basic and secondary education, engaging in a constructive dialogue on one of the most pressing issues facing education today. [1]

The purposes of the report are to stimulate attention to educational goals on the part of individuals, families, educational professionals, community leaders in business, religion, and politics, local governments, national governments, and international organizations, and to provide some starting points for future discussions among the different groups with different agendas that compose any society on the globe. The study is to explore the venues to come up with an Secondary Education model that can be applied in a global prospective in improve the education just in one courtly but internationally. [2]

In the study Joel Cohen have started the research by raising the following questions
What should be the goals of basic and secondary education of high quality?
Which, if any, of these goals should be universal? What does universal mean? What happens when educational goals conflict? What are the meanings of high quality in basic and secondary education? Who decides these questions, and by what process do they decide? How should the quality of decisions about educational goals be evaluated?

The report, Educating All Children: A Global Agenda, [3] by the academy, a Cambridge, Mass. based independent policy research center, outlines an ambitious plan for improving educational access that goes beyond the goals of existing international initiatives, which have long focused on primary education, to include secondary school. [5]

The research suggests that achieving universal primary and secondary education is both urgently needed and feasible. Will the international community commit the necessary economic, human, and political resources? The challenge, say the editors, is “as inspiring and formidable … as any extraterrestrial adventures and far more likely to enrich and improve life on earth.”

Despite the findings, the study by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences said the goal of providing a high-quality education to all children could be achieved at a reasonable cost with more support and funding from governments worldwide. “There’s no question that it’s possible,” said David Bloom, one of the authors of the study. “It’s a question of financial resources and it’s a question of political will.” “We … need to pay much more attention to education access at the secondary level and we need to pay attention to educational quality,” Bloom said. “It’s not just a question of getting kids into schools, it’s also a question of what you do with them once they’re in school.” The study attempted to lay out a vision of what the world would look like, “how much better the world would be if instead of using our resources for military purposes we used them to get every kid in the world into school and provide them with quality education.” [4]

There is no question on the fact that, achieving universal primary and secondary education is both urgently needed and feasible. Will the international community commit the necessary economic, human, and political resources? The main challenge is not financially oriented but rather on the leadership side. It is to have people to dedicate themselves on this cause which is inspiring and formidable … as any extraterrestrial adventures and far more likely to enrich and improve life on earth.

And, this is what Fethullah Gulen achieved so far. Gulen emphasizes the significance of educating younger generations with the idea of peaceful coexistence and mutual understanding.

The educational perspective of Fethullah Gulen is the illumination of the mind to science and knowledge, and the lighting of the heart in faith and virtue. This can be accomplished though teachers who are committed to devoting their lives, time and knowledge to teach the younger generations in these educational institutions.

And, the recent findings are speaking about the extraordinary achievement Gulen-inspired school demonstrated so far. There are currently more than 1000 Gulen-inspired schools in more than 110 countries around the world. In the European countries, there are at least a dozen Gulen-inspired schools, and more than 150 smaller educational and cultural centers. Generally, Gulen-inspired schools are low fee schools due to the limited wealth of supporters of these educational projects . [6].


To President Obama’s Muslim Advisor Mogahed, the Gulen Movement is a model and inspiration for all those working for the good of society, and is a highly admirable and impressive movement in the world.

Cemil Genc

[1]http://belfercenter.hks.harvard.edu/publication/19869/international_perspectives_on_the_goals_of_universal_basic_and_secondary_education.html?breadcrumb=%2Fexperts%2F210%2Fowen_r_cote
inspired by FG

[2] Cohen, Joel E. and Martin B. Malin, eds. International Perspectives on the Goals of Universal Basic and Secondary Education. New York: Routledge USA, December 2009.

[3] Cohen, Joel E., David E. Bloom, Martin B. Malin, eds. Educating All Children: A Global Agenda. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, January 2007.

[4] Reuters World falling behind on 2015 education goal Wed Jan 17, 2007 7:15 PM ET
By David Alexander

[5] Education Week Worldwide Education Achievable, Study Says Published: January 19, 2007
Vol. 26, Issue 20, Page 16 By Kathleen Kennedy Manzo

[6] The Key Factors behind the Success of Gulen-Inspired Schools. Ahmet Polat, Executive Officer of the Australian Intercultural Society.

Source:  http://www.charteradvocate.org/gulen-charter-schools/148-universal-schooling-and-gulen-insipred-schools

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Fethullah Gulen schools or Gulen-inspired schools?

First of all there no such definition as “Fethullah Gulen schools”. None of the schools have an official affiliation with Fethullah Gulen himself. There is no wayFethullah Gulen himself to involve in the establishment of such large number of schools which are scattered all over the world. And, it is humanly impossible to one person who lives in an isolated, remote region to manage the schools which are in different countries.

The missing part in this ordeal is not recognizing the influence of Fethullah Gulen in the world fast developing county, Turkey.

As the Turkish Secretary of State Davutoglu has mentioned, the biggest potential of Turkey is human capital. Turkey is not known for its everlasting natural resources. Turkey do not possess capital saving that was obtained through exploiting other nations. Turkey has not been known for its resources such as natural gas and oil as well. Nevertheless only one thing – the biggest resource of Turkey is the human capital – well-educated, young, and energetic but the most significantly human resource that is powerful belonging to their country, history and nation.

Fethullah Gulen has been extensively emphasising the importance of working hard to bring the society on to the higher levels of prosperity. In this bookPearls of Wisdom;

“Laziness and attachment to ease are among the major reasons for deprivation and humiliation. Inactive people who have abandoned themselves to (indolent) comfort one day will fall so low that they will expect even their basic necessities to be supplied by others.

For a human being, change and decay are usually slow and silent. Sometimes even a little heedlessness, a slight straying from the “caravan,” can cause a complete collapse and a total loss. However, because those who have fallen see themselves as still on the same line and in the same situation, they do not realize that they have plunged to the bottom of a deep well from a minaret-like peak.

Some people who leave the line of exertion and struggle with a feeling of guilt, which every fugitive and truant is bound to feel, are likely to defend themselves and criticize their friends who continue to serve. It is almost impossible for such people to escape their deviation and return to their original line.”[2]


People who were inspired by Fethullah Gulen have achieved autonomy from state power and has been able to play a significant role in society, the main characteristics of civil society organizations. Turkey is also a country which has undergone an economic transformation in recent years. And, the influence ofFethullah Gulen cannot be underestimated on this aspect of the Turkey’s economic growth.

In his book, Fethullah Gulen writes: “Those who want to reform the world must first reform themselves. If they want to lead others to a better world, they must purify their inner worlds of hatred and jealousy, and adorn their outer worlds with virtue. The words of those who cannot control and discipline themselves, and who have not refined their feelings, may seem attractive and insightful at first. However, even if they somehow manage to inspire others, which they sometimes do, the sentiments they arouse will soon wither.” [2]

In addition, thanks to the Turkey-EU Customs Union which came into force in 1996, Turkey has enjoyed customs-free exports to a market of over 500 million people. Apart from EU integration, Turkey is playing a leading role in several international bodies, such as the World Trade Organization, OECD, and Black Sea Economic Cooperation. Turkey has been promoting peace, stability, democracy and economic welfare in its region and beyond. Turkey is one of the three standalone countries, which was declared by the African Union as a strategic partner, after China and India, in January 2008. So far, development projects in 37 African countries have already been conducted. [3]. Turkey is a success story when the majority of the developed countries suffering from the economic turmoil. Today, Turkey is a secular state with no Islamic reference. It offers an open political space that allows for all political ideologies to compete free. [1]

Fethullah Gulen has been trying to encourage generations to come to improve themselves to better people to make their positive impact to the world around themselves... Fethullah Gulen wrote “ the generation who aim to give a better shape to the world should be equipped with mathematical thought. Mathematical thought implies a comprehension of the enigmatic connection between creation and the ‘laws’ of mathematics, and a discovery of the mysterious world of numbers. Without mathematics, it is not possible to perceive the mutual relations between man and things; it is mathematics which, like a source of light, illuminates our way along the line from the universe to life and shows us the depths of the world of possibilities beyond human imagination, thus enabling us to attain our ideals” [4]

[1] http://www.nationmultimedia.com/opinion/Turkey-a-success-story-of-tripartite-coexistence-30181222.html

[2] http://en.fgulen.com/

[3] Mr Zafer Çağlayan, State Minister for Foreign Trade. http://www.biz-works.net/index.php5?&;fl=y&pgid=ar&art=1001_08

[4] Towards the lost paradise

Source: http://gulenmovement.com/latest-news/143-fethullah-gulen-schools-or-gulen-inspired-schools

Saturday, July 28, 2012

Gulen Inspired Schools / Gulen Charter Schools

In the last two years, a new trend has been started by some mysterious bloggers later joined by a few self-identified scholars with PhDs. They came up with a brand-new term, a totally new coinage, for the charter school world: Gulen Charter Schools. While the early-bird alarmist bloggers tried to attract people’s attention to those so-called Gulen Charter Schools by claiming that Fethullah Gulen involved in the foundation and administration of some US charter schools, others – specifically the academics – based their arguments on these blogs as if the latter were highly credible sources. Moreover, in an effort to make their claims look authentic alarmist bloggers employed Charter Schools’ open-to-public data, such as tax returns and H1B visa applications which indeed have been scrutinized by local and federal government agencies many times for various procedural reasons.
The question here is what charter schools are and in what sense they could be compared with the schools founded throughout the world by the people inspired by Fethullah Gulen.
According to uscharterschools.org;

Charter schools are nonsectarian public schools of choice that operate with freedom from many of the regulations that apply to traditional public schools. The “charter” establishing each such school is a performance contract detailing the school’s mission, program, goals, students served, methods of assessment, and ways to measure success. The length of time for which charters are granted varies, but most are granted for 3-5 years. At the end of the term, the entity granting the charter may renew the school’s contract. Charter schools are accountable to their sponsor– usually a state or local school board– to produce positive academic results and adhere to the charter contract. The basic concept of charter schools is that they exercise increased autonomy in return for this accountability. They are accountable for both academic results and fiscal practices to several groups: the sponsor that grants them, the parents who choose them and the public that funds them.

Uscharterschools.org also provides some other definitions of charter schools from various independent sources such as this one:

Charter schools are semi-autonomous public schools, founded by educators, parents, community groups or private organizations that operate under a written contract with a state, district or other entity. This contract, or charter, details how the school will be organized and managed, what students will be taught and expected to achieve, and how success will be measured. Many charter schools enjoy freedom from rules and regulations affecting other public schools, as long as they continue to meet the terms of their charters. Charter schools can be closed for failing to satisfy these terms. (“Charter Schools Description”, Education Commission of the States, 2005)

These definitions clearly state that charter schools are public institutions owned by the public, operated for the sake of public by using public money, and responsible to the institutions representing the public. They have to be transparent – as dictated by the laws in the US – open to public by providing equal opportunity of enrollment to anyone legally eligible for the application to the school, cannot discriminate even by requiring certain test scores as a requirement for enrollment. Charter schools are operated by contractors for a specified term and the contract could be renewed based on the schools’ performance. They are accountable for their academic and fiscal performances to the institution (state, local school board etc) who granted them this privilege in the name of public. This means the contractors do not really own the schools but operate them for a pre-arranged time period. Then, if the contract is renewed they are good to go; but if not, it turns into a regular, government operated public school overnight.

Academics studying Gulen-inspired schools founded throughout the world by the people who were inspired by Fethullah Gulen’s teachings have coined the term Gulen Schools (or Gulen-inspired schools/institutions) for convenience purposes (see Ebaugh, 2010, p. 96). Although Fethullah Gulen does not accept any affiliation to his name, whether it is people or institutions, it has been useful to call them Gulen Schools. Fr. Thomas Michel describes Gulen Schools as follows:

[T]he schools inspired by Gülen’s educational understanding are not religious or Islamic. Instead, they are secular private schools inspected by state authorities and sponsored by parents and entrepreneurs. They follow secular, state-prescribed curricula and internationally recognized programs. (Michel, 2006, p. 111)

Gulen-inspired schools, unlike charter schools, are private schools financed by tuition fees and donations of local businessmen who pledged their support at school fundraisers that are held on yearly basis. They are open to public as long as students could pay the tuition and at the same time pass a certain qualification test held either by the school itself or – in Turkish case – by the state. For those who are well qualified without proper financial support, there are scholarships such as tuition waivers and even stipends. Moreover, these private schools are predominantly boarding schools where there usually is no option other than living in the dormitories under the tutelage of school administration.

The business circles of the movement are the main sponsors of these schools, supporting them financially until they are able to raise their own revenues through school fees. In each country, the community works in co-operation with the local authorities, who often provide logistical assistance and supervise the curriculum:

Some schools are completely built and funded by businessmen and industrialists, while some are joint ventures between the state and the trusts. The state provides the building, electricity, water, etc., and the trusts provide teaching, the teaching staff, and all educational materials and resources.

Some are eventually completely funded by student fees. They work as non-profitable companies or trusts, that is, all the income incurred goes back to the students again as educational investment (new teaching materials and resources such as books, computers, software; and facilities such as labs, gyms, hostels, residence halls, etc).

Ruth Woodhall says, “Every school has its own independent accountants and accountancy system. They are all accountable to the local authorities (the state) and the trust’s inspectors, and comply with the state and international law.”[1] Ian G. Williams adds that the schools do receive summary and unpredicted inspections.[2] On the other hand, a qualitative field research about Kenya’s Gülen-inspired schools suggests that the schools have been functioning not only as a secular alternative to religious, Christian missionary schools and Islamic schools, but also as barriers to potential ethno-religious conflict between Kenya’s local Christian tribes and its politically empowering Muslim minority.[3]

Charter schools allegedly affiliated to Fethullah Gulen and mistakenly called Gulen Charter Schools have none of the above mentioned characteristics that Gulen-inspired schools display. They are neither founded as private institutions, nor funded by private entrepreneurs and they are not allowed to charge any sort of tuition fee let alone putting enrollment requirements to select students that have promising academic potential. They don’t administer any entrance or qualification test. Unlike Gulen-inspired schools, charter schools have almost no donations from generous businessmen. If there is any donation, it probably comes from certain foundations like Dell Foundation or Gates Foundation within the scope of a larger project or initiative such as T-STEM. The budget of a charter school largely consists of the state money that is paid annually to each and every charter school in the nation. Charter schools also may not make zip code distinction as public schools and more than half of their students, statistics show that, come from disadvantaged areas. There is also no boarding school option as in the example of Gulen-inspired schools. Charter schools are day schools; therefore there are no dormitories that students can stay overnight.

Here remains a question: Is there any Gulen-inspired school in the sense that I have described above? I can say “Yes,” this question. There are indeed handful Gulen-inspired private schools in the United States. One of them is the Pinnacle Academy of Northern Virginia (DC metropolitan area). Lately they have attracted the attention of the national and international media after President Obama hosted Inaugural White House Science Fair. Pinnacle team developed a digital and three-dimensional model of “Yeshilist,” an imaginary city that anticipates the accommodation needs of citizens who lose their homes during an earthquake and they introduced their project to President Obama at the White House.

Another Gulen-inspired school is Brooklyn Amity School, a well-known school by its achievements at some of the top academic competitions such as Science Olympiad, Math Contests, Robotics Competitions, Art Contests, and Future City Engineering competition.

I guess there are five or six Gulen-inspired schools in the US and those schools have no connection with some other charter schools called mistakenly Gulen Charter Schools. As I stated in my article entitled Gulen Charter Schools, the fact that some people inspired by Fethullah Gulen work for a charter school does not necessarily make this school a Gulen Charter School.

Finally, I need to reiterate the fact that we should definitely make a distinction and put some space between Gulen-inspired schools and the non-existent concept of Gulen Charter Schools mistakenly claimed by some alarmist bloggers. I have described the nature of Gulen-inspired schools and their main differences from US charter schools. I hope self-proclaimed academics won’t fall into the trap of mistakenly-coined Gulen Charter Schools concept again.

[1] Ruth Woodhall, “Organizing the Organization, Educating the Educators: An Examination of Fethullah Gulen’s Teaching and the Membership of the Movement, delivered during “Islam in the Contemporary World: The Fethullah Gulen Movement in Thought and Practice” conference, Rice University, 12-13 November, 2005, pp.3-4
[2] Ian G. Williams, “An Absent Influence? The Nurcu/Fetullah Gulen Movements in Turkish Islam and Their Potential Influence upon European Islam and Global Education”, delivered during “Islam in the Contemporary World: The Fethullah Gulen Movement in Thought and Practice” conference, Rice University, 12-13 November, 2005, pp.8.
[3] Mehmet Kalyoncu, “Gulen-inspired Schools in the East Africa: Secular Alternative in Kenya and Pragmatist Approach to Development in Uganda”, delivered during “Islam in the Age of Global Challenges: Alternative Perspectives of the Gulen Movement” conference on November 14-15, 2008, Georgetown University, p.1

Source: Charter Advocate, http://www.charteradvocate.org/gulen-charter-schools/76-gulen-inspired-charter-schools